Footsteps in the Fog – Alfred Hitchcock’s San Francisco by Jeff Kraft and Aaron Levanthal
2002 – Santa Monica Press – 286 pages
As Alfred Hitchcock’s daughter Pat states in her foreword to this book, Hitchcock had a fondness for the Bay Area. He thought of San Francisco as a very cosmopolitan city, which he enjoyed both personally and professionally.
This volume details the movies that Hitchcock filmed in the greater Bay Area. There are chapters on Shadow of a Doubt, Vertigo, and The Birds, as well as a chapter highlighting a few scenes from other Hitchcock films that were shot in the area. The book closes with a chapter on Hitchcock’s personal connection to the Bay Area.
This book is a detailed pictorial representation of where the movies were filmed. The authors go through the movies chronologically, and as the plot is outlined, they share the very specific location where every scene was filmed. There are literally hundreds of black and white photographs, comparing the locations as they appeared in the movies, with their appearance at the time the book was being researched and written.
There are also several detailed maps and sidebars that offer more of San Francisco’s history.
For anyone who is planning a “Hitchcock tour” of Northern California, this volume is absolutely indispensable. I had it with me when I traveled to Santa Rosa, San Francisco, and Bodega Bay, and it came in handy more than once.
I also learned quite a bit about several Hitchcock films, such as the way Hitchcock altered the geography of the Bodega Bay area on screen to serve his narrative purposes. Also, I never knew that Hitchcock filmed some scenes from Family Plotin San Francisco, or that a handful of the “Cuban” scenes from Topaz were filmed near Salinas.
My only quibble with this book is the layout. It is a “coffee-table” style book, about 8 inches tall and 11 wide, which makes it a bit awkward in paperback form to hold and turn pages, especially when referring to it while travelling. This is of course no slight against the authors, who clearly spent a considerable amount of time compiling their material for this book, and did an admirable job.
If you are from the Bay Area, or plan to visit, then this book is recommended.
There are a lot of great camera moments in Shadow of a Doubt. Rather than an in-depth look at one scene, I decided to do a more brief overview of several scenes. Although there are several standard coverage shots in this film, they are interspersed with moments of ingenuity. Hitchcock never let the camera set-ups become boring.
Charlie visits the library and learns a secret
When young Charlie (Teresa Wright) reads the newspaper at the library she discovers an article that both implicates her uncle in a series of murders and offers explanation for the inscription on her ring. Hitchcock has the camera start tight in on the ring then pull back, and keep pulling back, until the camera is far above the library floor. This bold camera move heightens Charlie’s shock, and her feeling of being alone with her knowledge. This scene is incredibly well lit too. Joseph A Valentine was the cinematographer on this film, and two others for Hitchcock.
2. Uncle Charlie’s monologue
It wouldn’t be a Hitchcock movie if he didn’t use subjective point of view at least once. As the Newton family sit at the dinner table, Uncle Charlie (Joseph Cotten) begins to talk about widows. As he speaks he becomes more passionate, and his choice of words more shocking. We are watching Uncle Charlie in profile, from niece Charlie’s point of view on her uncle’s right. As he speaks of “horrible, faded, fat greedy women” the camera slowly zooms in, until his face fills the screen. Then young Charlie, off camera, mentions that these women are alive, are human beings. Uncle Charlie whips his head to the right. “Are they?” he asks Charlie, and us as well, looking directly into the camera. This is a moment of considerable tension, and the first time we really understand just what a monster Uncle Charlie could be.
3. Trapped in the garage
After Uncle Charlie’s plan to trap his niece in the garage fails, and she survives death by carbon monoxide, the family is gathered outside the house preparing to leave. Hitchcock does something very clever here. He wants to give Mrs. Newton a close-up as she contemplates her daughter’s close call, and he does so with staging rather than with a zoom. The family are standing together. As they climb in the taxi, Mrs. Newton gets in the back seat and slides over to the driver’s side. At the same time, with no cut, the camera dollies down the driver’s side of the car, stopping on Mrs. Newton’s window. She has just moved into a close-up! After she delivers her line of dialogue, the taxi pulls away, leaving young Charlie small and alone. Still with no editorial cut, she turns and walks to the house.
4. The ring on the stairs
After the speech, Uncle Charlie is proposing a toast. He is happy, believing he has won. At first he smiles as his niece descends the stairs. Then he realizes that she has stolen back the incriminating ring, which now rests on her finger. Checkmate. The smile drains from Uncle Charlie’s face.
None of these camera moves draw attention to themselves on first viewing. They are all driven by the motivations of the characters, and contribute greatly to the emotional tension. Hitchcock was ever the experimenter, looking for new ways to allow the camera to tell the story. Shadow of a Doubt is one of his greatest achievements.
In my posted review of Alfred Hitchcock’s movie Shadow of a Doubt I wrote that Edna May Wonacott (who played Ann Newton in the film), gives the best performance by a child actor in the entire Hitchcock canon. And there are quite a few memorable ones: Veronica Cartwright in The Birds, Desmond Tester in Sabotage, and Jerry Mathers in The Trouble with Harry spring to mind.
What makes Edna’s performance stand out? Her character Ann Newton is wise beyond her years. Other members of the Newton family treat her like a child, (which she certainly is), but she makes very mature observations. Edna’s character gets many of the best lines in the movie, and many of them produce a smile. My favorite line involves her character Ann commenting on her mother speaking very loud into the telephone: “she thinks she has to cover the distance by sheer lung power”, quips Ann, a line rumored to be inspired by Alfred Hitchcock’s own mother. I also find it very significant that Ann is the only member of the Newton family who is on to her Uncle Charlie from the moment he steps off the train. She knows that something is not quite right with him. And Edna plays the part superbly. It’s a performance I always enjoy, in a movie I’ve seen many times.
When I began to research Edna May Wonacott online, I soon learned that she is now Edna Green, and that she has quite a few fans. The Lady Eve (who writes a blog on classic movies right here on wordpress and other sites as well) wrote a fantastic piece about Edna, which piqued my interest even further. I was determind to write to Edna, and ask if she would consent to an interview for my blog. Edna not only did reply, but graciously agreed to answer all of my questions about “innumerable things”, to steal a line from her character in the movie. What follows is the complete text of our interview.
Steve: How did you come to be cast in Shadow of a Doubt?
Edna: I was standing on a street corner in Santa Rosa waiting for a bus to go home. We had relatives visiting and my cousins and I went to town shopping. Alfred Hitchcock and Jack Skirball the producer were standing on that corner looking at the intersection and discussing it, and I was kind of wondering what they were doing, and all of a sudden they started looking at me. My older cousin wasn’t too happy about it and made me move away, and they still continued looking at me, and finally walked over to us and introduced themselves, and said they were going to make a movie in town and wanted to know if I would like to be in it! Of course I said yes, and they said they would come out to our house and talk to my parents. Then the bus came and we went home. That afternoon they came out to the house and talked to my parents, and my mother and I went to Hollywood for a screen test, and that was how it got started.
Did you become something of a celebrity in Santa Rosa?
Edna: Naturally everybody in town was curious and lots of people came to my father’s grocery store that he owned, and wanted to touch the father of a movie star! There was lots of publicity about it and lots of people watching the making of the movie since most of it was filmed on location in Santa Rosa.
The ensemble cast in this film is amazing. Everyone played their part so perfectly. Did you bond as a group, when the camera was not rolling?
Edna: It was like a job for all of us, and we became good friends as coworkers do. We didn’t get together other than work. I did become a close friend with Alfred Hitchcock’s daughter (Patricia) and when we went to Hollywood to finish the picture I would sometimes go out to their house for weekends. That was fun.
It seems to me Teresa Wright had the most difficult role in this film, and she gives an outstanding performance. What was it like to work with “big sister” Teresa?
Edna: She was very nice, and so was everybody else who worked on the picture. We were like a big family and had a good time. Lots of practical jokes being played on each other and lots of laughs.
Your character, Ann Newton, is the only one in the family who is immediately suspicious of Uncle Charlie. Did you receive any specific directions on how to play your scenes with Joseph Cotten? Did Hitchcock give alot of direction on the set to you and the other actors?
Edna: I can’t say there were any specific instructions given. Hitchcock just explained to me how my character felt about “Uncle Charlie” and more or less let me do my own thing. He wanted not only my part but everybody’s part very natural and that was what I did. I did just what he asked of me and I guess it pleased him. He always described the scenes to us and it just seemed to come naturally. It was very easy to understand what he wanted and that was how it came out.
If you don’t mind a little character analysis, why do you think Ann was on to Uncle Charlie so quickly?
Edna: I was only nine at the time and didn’t really give any thought to why Ann felt the way she did. I can’t remember if I even knew the whole story until I saw the completed movie when it was made. When a movie is made it’s not filmed in the sequence of the story. We knew the night before what was being shot for the next day and that was the part you learned.
In his autobiography, Joseph Cotten said the screenplay for “Shadow of a Doubt” was so good that hardly a word was changed on the set. Your character gets some of the best lines in the movie. Do you recall if the dialogue was changed much?
Edna: I don’t have any idea if the original dialogue was changed or not. Probably not. I didn’t really give much thought to what my lines were and just did what they wanted me to. I know I had a good time everyday and enjoyed every minute of it. Mainly because of having such nice people to work with. Not only the actors but also all of the crew.
“Shadow of a Doubt” is one of Hitchcock’s most celebrated films of his early American period. It routinely makes “best film” lists, airs on television and at film festivals. Why do you think this film holds up so well, over 60 years after its release?
Edna: It amazes me that the film is still so popular and everybody seems to remember it. It is really one of the true classics and I feel really proud to have been a part of it. I carry really fond memories for that part of my life, and I am thankful to have such a blessed time of my life on film, so to speak. I also have lots of scrap books and have been invited to lots of functions to show my scrap books and share that part of my life. In fact I still receive fan mail and a lot of it in the last few months has been coming from Europe. Lots of people in their 30’s and 40’s are turning to the classic films nowadays.
I would like to extend my deepest thanks to Edna May Wonacott for taking the time to share her memories from the making of Shadow of a Doubt, one of Alfred Hitchcock’s best, and most personal, films.
SHADOW OF A DOUBT (1943) – Universal Studios – Rating: ★★★★½
B&W – 106 mins. – 1.33:1 aspect ratio
Directed by Alfred Hitchcock
Principal Cast: Teresa Wright (Charlotte “Charlie” Newton), Joseph Cotten (Charlie Oakley), MacDonald Carey (Jack Graham), Henry Travers (Joseph Newton), Patricia Collinge (Emma Newton), Hume Cronyn (Herbie Hawkins), Wallace Ford (Fred Saunders), Edna May Wonacott (Ann Newton), Charles Bates (Roger Newton).
Produced by Jack H. Skirball
Written by Thornton Wilder & Alma Reville & Sally Benson, from a story by Gordon McDonell
Director of Photography: Joseph A. Valentine
Film Editing: Milton Carruth
Original music: Dmitri Tiomkin
Charles Oakley lies on his bed in a nondescript boardinghouse. He is a picture of ennui, and everything about him suggests carelessness, from the recumbent way he smokes his cigar to the money scattered on the floor. He stirs from his lassitude when the landlady informs him that two gentlemen asked about him; he then gathers his things and leaves, giving the “gentlemen” the slip. Suddenly a man of determination, he sends a telegram to his sister and her family in Santa Rosa, California, informing them of his intention to visit.
Dissolve to Santa Rosa, a picturesque American town. Oakley’s niece, “Charlie”, is lying on her bed, in much the same state as her uncle. She is in the dumps, and wants to do something to shake up the family. Suddenly an idea occurs to her, and she rushes to the telegraph office to invite her Uncle Charlie to visit. She arrives just in time to receive the telegram from her uncle announcing his impending arrival. It’s almost as if they were reading each other’s minds, speculates Charlie.
Soon thereafter Uncle Charlie arrives, descending from the train under a plume of dark smoke that presages the arrival of something sinister in sleepy Santa Rosa. At first the family is delighted to see him, from sister Emma Newton, to brother-in-law Joseph and the three children. Uncle Charlie brings fine gifts for everyone, including an emerald ring for his favorite niece, his namesake Charlie. The ring inexplicably has in inscription, initials that Uncle Charlie insists were not put there by him. She does not care, saying that makes the ring more precious, because somebody happy had worn it before her.
Two men arrive at the Newton home who claim to be conducting a survey. They wish to ask questions of the household and take photographs. Uncle Charlie is evasive, refusing to be involved and bordering on rudeness when he encounters the two men in the home. Could these be the same “gentlemen” who were inquiring after Charlie at his boardinghouse? Soon enough niece Charlie learns from one of the men that they are police, and are indeed on the trail of her uncle, who may be involved in some pretty nasty crimes, namely the murder of several widows and the theft of their money. Charlie does not want her mother to know, for it would break her heart. She begins an investigation of her own, and soon discovers the answer to the question of her uncle’s guilt or innocence. This portion of the story involves a cat-and-mouse interplay between uncle and niece, with the rest of the family ignorant of the situation and implications. At the same time Charlie begins an awkward romance with the detective who had tipped her to her uncle’s situation.
The contest of wills between the two Charlies seems to be won by niece Charlie, and her uncle agrees to leave Santa Rosa. On the train that will take him away, he tries to silence his niece’s suspicions, with deadly consequences.
Performance: This is arguably one of the best casts in any Hitchcock film, from top to bottom. Joseph Cotten is perfect as Uncle Charlie, creating one of Hitchcock’s greatest villains. Teresa Wright as niece Charlie has the most difficult part in the movie, as her character undergoes a dramatic transformation when she learns several truths about her uncle, and the world. Henry Travers, who will forever be known to movie lovers as Clarence the angel in Frank Capra’s It’s A Wonderful Life, is pleasant and likeable as the Newton family patriarch. His primary job is to provide occasional comic relief. But the most memorable, and most moving performance in the film belongs to Patricia Collinge as Uncle Charlie’s sister Emma. Emma’s fondness for her younger brother is palpable, as is her fondness for childhood recollections. If there is one performance that is not entirely perfect it is that of MacDonald Carey as Detective Graham. He seems out-of-place in some of his onscreen interplay.
Writing: Thornton Wilder, who wrote the quintessential American idyll Our Town, was the principle screenwriter. Hitchcock charged Wilder with creating another slice of small-town American life, and introducing menace into it. And Wilder’s writing is pitch perfect. His tone ranges from the charming and occasionally comic portrait of the Newton family, to Uncle Charlie’s almost shockingly dark monologues about modern big-city life. Hitchcock was so impressed that he gave Wilder a special acknowledgment in the opening credits, in addition to his screenwriting credit.
The doppelgänger effect: The central relationship in this movie is that of the two Charlies, uncle and niece. The idea of the characters as doubles appears frequently. First as they both appear sprawled on a bed in their respective opening scenes. Later in several lines of dialogue. Teresa Wright as Charlie tells her uncle “We’re sort of like twins, don’t you see?”Later Uncle Charlie accosts his niece outside a bar called “Til Two”, finally taking her inside. There are no overt incestuous signals in this relationship, but it is a very odd relationship for an uncle and niece. She gazes at him longingly in their opening scenes together, and when she walks through town with him, arm in arm, she is delighted when her friends look at him in awe, almost as if she wants them to think he is her beau. What Uncle Charlie doesn’t foresee is that his niece has an inner mettle that has remained hidden, and it only comes to the forefront as she is forced to confront him. They are indeed very much alike, and it is this that allows her to best him in their game of wits.
The precocious girl: Women in Hitchcock movies are often the dominant partner in a relationship. They are often more intelligent and resourceful than their male counterpart. This also applies to young girls. In this film, the younger daughter Ann Newton, (played delightfully by Edna May Wonacott) is wise beyond her years. She is constantly reading and repeating things she has learned in her books. She is also the only member of the Newton family that is never taken in by Uncle Charlie. She is suspicious of him from the first moment she lays eyes on him, and although she never learns the nature of his crimes, she is not fooled. Wonacott gives the best performance by a child in the entire Hitchcock canon, in my opinion. Meanwhile the young boy Roger (played by Charles Bates) is a typical boy child, who does have one great reaction shot, played for comic effect, when Patricia Collinge says the youngest child is always spoiled.
Merry widow waltz: This waltz plays over the opening credits, along with footage of waltzing couples, which looks like stock footage but Hitchcock said he filmed specifically. The waltz features prominently in a dinner table scene, and Hitchcock uses the dancing couples footage as a transitional shot at a couple of key moments in the film. This is a very interesting expressionistic touch.
Dark humor: Hume Cronyn provides some dark humor as Herbie Hawkins, friend to Joe Newton. Hawkins and Newton read whodunits, and discuss the best way to kill each other, not realizing that they are only a few feet away from someone with practical experience! There is also perhaps a subtle indication that Herbie would like to do away with his mother, yet another charming mother/son relationship.
Emma Newton as Emma Hitchcock: Alfred Hitchcock’s mother Emma passed away during production of this film. There is much speculation that the character of Emma Newton (the name can be no coincidence) was inspired in part by the director’s own mother. Certainly Emma Newton, as played so wonderfully by Patricia Collinge, is allowed a sentimentality that is seldom if ever seen in Hitchcock films. Her emotional response to the news that her brother will be leaving is so genuine, that it almost moves the viewer to tears, particularly because of the things we know about her brother Charlie that she does not.
What Joe said: Joseph Cotten, in his 1987 autobiography Vanity Will Get You Somewhere, said of this film that “it is certainly mentioned to me as often as Citizen Kane and The Third Man.” He also complimented Thornton Wilder’s screenplay, saying “I cannot remember any shooting script that suffered so few alterations during production. All the actors agreed that the author’s words were not only easy to learn, but a pleasure to speak.”
Academy awards: Gordon McDonell received a nomination in the now defunct “Best Writing, Original Story” category.
Recurring players: Joseph Cotten would star later in Under Capricorn. Hume Cronyn would appear in Hitchcock’s next film, Lifeboat. Wallace Ford would turn up in Spellbound, as would Irving Bacon. Frances Carson appeared in Foreign Correspondentand Saboteur. Edward Fielding was also in Rebecca, Suspicionand Spellbound. Constance Purdy also appeared in Spellbound. Byron Shores was in Saboteur. And Eily Malyon, the perfect spinsterish librarian, had earlier played the perfect spinsterish hotel desk clerk in Foreign Correspondent.
Where’s Hitch? Alfred Hitchcock’s cameo appears at about 16:26. He is seen from a right rear profile as a passenger on the train. He is playing cards with a doctor and his wife, and the camera shows that his hand is the entire suit of spades!
Legacy: Universal remade this movie in 1958, as a noirish B-movie called Step Down to Terror. It was also remade for TV in 1991, with Mark Harmon in the Uncle Charlie role.
Hitchcock moment: For the most part this movie was shot in a very straightforward manner, with Hitchcock’s usual economy of shots. The shot in the library where the camera pulls back from a close-up looking over Teresa Wright’s shoulder, high up to the ceiling, is impressive. Production designer Bob Boyle said that Hitchcock wanted the camera movement to be almost like a gasp, or sudden intake of breath. There is also the shot of Teresa Wright coming downstairs with her hand on the bannister, as the camera slowly zooms in on her hand, and the emerald ring plainly visible on it.
What Hitch said: Numerous critics say that this was Hitchcock’s favorite among his own films. His daughter Patricia states it unequivocally: “It was my father’s favorite picture.” One would think she would know. When pressed on this point by Truffaut, Hitchcock answered: “I wouldn’t say that Shadow of a Doubt is my favorite picture; if I’ve given that impression, it’s probably because I feel that here is something that our friends, the plausibles and logicians, cannot complain about.” (In referring to the “plausibles” Hitchcock was talking about people who dismissed the plots of his films because they were not plausible). “But that impression is also due to my very pleasant memories of working on it with Thornton Wilder.”
Definitive edition: The best edition of this movie available for purchase today is Universal’s 2012 blu-ray release, (also available as part of the Masterpiece Collection box set). The picture quality is not quite as sharp as the blu-ray remaster of Saboteur, being a little grainy at times, but it still looks spectacular for a movie that is over 70 years old. The audio track (2-channel mono) also sounds quite good. Extra features include a 35-minute making-of documentary, which has interview footage with Hume Cronyn, Teresa Wright, Patricia Hitchcock, Robert Boyle, and Peter Bogdanovich. Also included are production drawings, production photographs, and the original theatrical trailer.